JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

New feature Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings View Demo

Hi there! Beta version

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

National Times

PM bares himself for a flogging, and may get it

Michelle Grattan
March 1, 2010

Opinion

Kevin Rudd has donned the hair-shirt in a tack that will leave many of his colleagues wondering exactly where his head is at.

By conceding that he has not been on top of his game, Rudd is adding grist to Tony Abbott's argument that the PM is more talk than action.

You'd think, from Rudd's resort to this pitch, that the government was way behind and seriously staring at defeat. But even those who think Abbott has performed well aren't predicting he's likely to win.

The insulation affair has been a disaster, exposing the government's flawed processes. Rudd's assumption of responsibility for it last week, including his regret for not being inquisitive enough, was proper and sensible, although his treatment of Peter Garrett was all over the place - on Tuesday saying he would be standing by his minister, on Friday cutting off his arm.

But yesterday's mea culpa was of a different ilk. It extended far wider. Rudd is now admitting he has been under-delivering, and he is sloughing off the cover of the global financial crisis. People have become disappointed in the government, he said, talking about the need for it to lift its game not just in the area of hospitals, where the timetable has slipped substantially, but education (Julia Gillard might think she has been marching along quite smartly) and ''getting on with the business of action on climate change''.

You imagine Abbott slipping easily into confession, but it comes as a bit of a shock from Rudd.

Leaving aside insulation, there is a danger in talking up the government's failings. Some voters who have been satisfied might think that if the PM believes they should give it a whack, perhaps they should. The ''flog me, flog me'' invitation might be irresistible.

The alternative argument is that it does no harm to appear humble; it can counter criticism that Rudd has looked too pumped up, hubristic and fond of the international limelight.

Public reaction over the next weeks will test the tactic.

Most immediately, the government has got itself into a bizarre bind. Its health policy, proposing it should become the major funder of hospitals, is ready to go. If it drops it immediately it is accused of another distraction, while every day it holds it back is a day lost on a frontline issue for those voters wanting better delivery from the PM.

Michelle Grattan is The Age's political editor.

42 comments

  • Another stunt from the Hollow Men. The words don't mean any more than the wild promises and even wilder spending - just a means to a re election. The only issue in all this, as far as I can see, is whether he gets away with it.

    Commenter
    Matt
    Location
    Neutral Bay
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 6:08AM
  • The big problem hasn't cume up for Rudd yet. And that is the $43 billion promise of a white elephant national broadband network. This disaster will make the insulation fiasco look like a sunday school picnic.

    Commenter
    Sydneyla
    Location
    Manly
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 6:38AM
  • Kevin Rudd has enough jaw for another set of teeth !!

    Commenter
    Wendy
    Location
    Sunshine Coast
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 7:38AM
  • Good article, Michelle. While no polly is the messiah, it appeared KR had the smarts enough to defeat the cons at their own game. I still feel that if he manages his hair shirt well enough that he might get through all the reforms necessary to undo Howard's shameless pork-barreling and to fix some of the glaring inequities in our society. I've no doubt that yon Kev has more reforms in his bag of tricks. But I'm beginning to wonder if he has the cojones to last at it. I hope so

    Commenter
    BillR
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 7:38AM
  • A fascinating turn of events. Entirely probable that the majority of media will monster Rudd over this. But what will the punters think?

    Potentially an interesting test of national character. That much loved claim to being a nation that honours "fair dinkum" is now in the spotlight. A Prime Minister shoots straight. Will he be shot down for it? And if he is, the adage "We get the governments and politicians we deserve" will ring absolutely true.

    Commenter
    Low Def
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 7:26AM
  • Apparently you could all do a better job?
    And none of you are going to use the NBN?

    For god's sake people, for once we have a government that is actually doing some work on infrastructure, and they get panned for it.

    Commenter
    A.S
    Location
    Brunswick
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 7:40AM
  • No doubt Hypocrites R Us will be out in force. They are the ones who claim that Kevin Rudd is both too arrogant and too humble at the same time. They also claimed that the stimulus funding would take too long to roll out and now claim that it was rushed. The fact that the media prefers someone who illegally invaded a country killing and wounding hundreds of thousands of innocent women and children to someone who saved Australia from recession just shows the parlous state of the fourth estate in Australia.

    Commenter
    Paul
    Location
    Melb
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 7:53AM
  • Oh, for God's sake, give it a break, will you? Now that he has admitted to some mistakes (after journalists went for his jugular because he hadn't done so) these very same journalists now have the hide to say he didn't need to! The question is, do Australians really want a hard-right politician like Tony Abbott back in power, merrily cutting back on their wages, pulling more money out of hospitals and schools, cuddling up to the next war-hungry lunatic in the White House, and doing nothing to repair the damage done to their environment and the very air they breathe? Are they that easily led - by nothing more than an orchestrated onslaught designed to make news in an election year? I don't think so.

    Commenter
    EBAB
    Location
    St Lucia
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 8:06AM
  • Kevin from Brisbane that came down to save us ,sounds like he is seeking some S & M what with "floggings and botton lines".Which personality will he use next week??

    Commenter
    ernest
    Location
    Bathurst
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 8:05AM
  • Pauly pops, (Melb - March 01, 2010, 8:53AM) give it up will ya.
    No danger of electing Howard now, so we can safely get rid of Rudd who has shamelessly broken most of the major promises which got him elected in the first place, and now is proceeding with a compensation package to some of the scammers who got financially upset when he closed down the home insulation disaster.
    They really are totally incompetent, and they only got us out of the GFC by spending all of Howard/Costello's savings, and indebting Australia for the next few decades where we'll need another few coalition governments to again haul us out of Labor's debt.

    Commenter
    JohnB
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    March 01, 2010, 8:26AM

More comments

Comments are now closed