JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

New feature Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings View Demo

Hi there! Beta version

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

National Times

Gentle on Julia, tough on Tim, beef for Bill

Katharine Murphy
September 8, 2011

Opinion

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

At Home With Julia

Take a gently satirical look at Julia and Tim's private life.

Slight it certainly was, but not fundamentally unkind - to the Prime Minister at least.

At Home with Julia clothed its barbs with affection when it came to the PM.

Poor old Tim Mathieson was a different story. The ABC's new political satire pushed unflinchingly into every potential dimension of being the Prime Minister's male de facto partner - his imagined daily frustrations, the small accumulated humiliations of being ''Mr Gillard'' - the problem of being ''Todd'' as Bob Katter called him absently at one point.

Amanda Bishop and Phil Lloyd  in <i>At Home With Julia</i>.

Amanda Bishop and Phil Lloyd in At Home With Julia.

Or was it Ted?

It hardly mattered who he was, even if in episode one, there was vindication of sorts; a tantrum from Tim actually saved the day.

What did we learn of Mr Mathieson? Here was a figure reduced to shuffling aimlessly around The Lodge, enduring jokes from passing urchins (''hey Mr Julia, how about a hair cut?''), holding up women's' magazines in the vain hope he might be recognised, and haggling desperately over absent Australian beef when the three independents showed up uninvited (by him) to ruin his date night.

Poor ''Mr Gillard''.

Ms Gillard on the other hand, as she's portrayed in this series by Amanda Bishop, might just garner some sympathy from the public.

The flat vowels were there, as were the mannerisms. Captured was Gillard's sense of suburban ordinariness.

Paul Keating who won't get off the phone. Rob Oakeshott who talks incessantly and keeps introducing himself even though (as she calmly points out) they've actually met before. Bob Katter who wants to stop all imported food and puckers his mouth disconcertingly, like it's just encountered a lemon. Barack Obama, whom she's too busy to talk to. Wayne Swan who can't remember how many zeros to put in his column of figures without prompting. Kevin Rudd, who takes over the running of the cabinet meetings if she's late.

Apparently this Julia has just one challenge: the challenge of remaining unflappable when any normal person would get into bed, pull the doona over their head, and never get out again.

To emphasise this point Bishop's Julia glides, her head remains resolutely level as she walks and talks, like a duck sailing on a pond, willing itself to remain in formation, whatever the prevailing wind.

If this were a better series, funnier, sharper, more genuinely insightful, that characterisation could have been poignant. As it was, it was just a detail. Perhaps richness will come, for now it was just shorthand, a mimic's preparation, hardly a deep revelation.

Only Bill Shorten seemed to have the perfect life. If you missed the program last night, Bill Shorten was not a factional powerbroker from Victoria, it was the first couple's small dog.

Bill Shorten, the lucky devil, got everything. A loving pat from an affectionate and grateful Prime Minister. And a big chunk of Tim's wagyu steak.

Australia, make of that what you will.

Katharine Murphy is Age national affairs correspondent.

twitter Follow the National Times on Twitter: @NationalTimesAU

147 comments

  • Was it just me or was this truly awful??? I felt it should have been renamed "Kath and Kim Go to Canberra". I endured 15 minutes before switching off, switched back over in the hope it improved, and it hadn't. Mind-numbingly awful.

    Commenter
    Steve_J
    Location
    West Melbourne
    Date and time
    September 07, 2011, 11:40PM
  • The first episode was fantastic. I love Gillard's nicknames for Mathieson; 'tim tam', 't-rex', 'tea bag'. How wonderful and endearing. Please - keep them coming!!

    Commenter
    Ray
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 12:38AM
  • Oh dear, it's just not funny... nor clever...

    If comedy is going to be predicated on cliche's, then it must have damn fine writing to support that... and sadly "At home with Julia" fails dismally when it comes to the scripts.

    Might have worked as a 5 minute Comedy Company skit twenty years ago, but as a 2011 ABC Series Comedy? No..sorry.

    Commenter
    David
    Location
    Brunswick
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 1:53AM
  • Bob Katter was the show stealer. Had me in stitches

    Commenter
    MarkyB
    Location
    Keilor East
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 5:52AM
  • Is this a cynical effort by the ABC to make Julia Gillard more human and likable to us, and less robotic ?

    Commenter
    Cynic
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 7:14AM
  • Finally a reason to vote for Julia Gillard. If we keep her in then they will be able to make more series of this excellent comedy. The depiction of Katter, Oakeshot and Windsor was brilliant. Sadly though for us, it was probably close to the mark.

    Commenter
    Sy
    Location
    Prahran
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 7:25AM
  • A very clever and funny show - and it is years since Australian TV has seen political comment like it. Congratulations to the writers.

    Commenter
    Great
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 7:35AM
  • Come on guys, give it a go. One episode does not a series make. Yes they did take the P#$% out of John Howard and others, only they were puppets. How about giving things a run before we arrogantly dismiss them. I t was a laugh, sometimes maybe strained, My Wife is Brazilian, try listening to comedy and explaining the characters, the actual jokes etc, it was hard, but it was fun. Get with the program, give them a go.Loved bob, poor old paul even got into the act, enjoyed a thirty minute break from advertising and CSI.

    Commenter
    A Start
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 7:44AM
  • What is wrong with some of you people - how could you not laugh at that show?! It was very funny and my partner and I got quite a few laughs...

    ...a dog named Bill Shorten (Always yapping at the PM's ankles!)
    ....The PM using a mug with Kevin 07 on it
    ....Mad Katter...and the other 2 independents

    Very funny show and I'm sure it will rate well...not sure "funny' is to some of the people commenting and would love to know what you watch that makes you laugh!

    I do like watching Angry Boys, but I think this is a bit better and can't wait for the next episode! And I can't wait to see if Idiot Abbott makes an appearance! That will be gold! Or even Hockey...they could have a field day!

    Great work..well done!

    Commenter
    AM PM
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 7:49AM
  • I think I raised a half smile but can't remember what it was now. My wife, who finds even the awful Kath & Kim funny, walked out to do something more pressing...folding the laundry, I think.

    Commenter
    Matt
    Location
    Neutral Bay
    Date and time
    September 08, 2011, 8:13AM

More comments

Comments are now closed

More Related Coverage

Amanda Bishop and Phil Lloyd  in At Home With Julia


Tim and JuliaClick to play video

Video

At Home With Julia

Take a gently satirical look at Julia and Tim's private life.