JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

New feature Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings View Demo

Hi there! Beta version

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

National Times

Canada's champ shows up our sourpuss - but for how long?

Bernard Lagan
February 16, 2010

Opinion

Canada's Alexandre Bilodeau celebrates after winning the final of the Men s Freestyle Skiing Moguls event at Cypress Mountain during the Vancouver Winter Olympics on February 14, 2010

Canada s Alexandre Bilodeau celebrates after winning the final of the Men s Freestyle Skiing Moguls event at Cypress Mountain during the Vancouver Winter Olympics on February 14, 2010

Your correspondent writes from old Quebec City, snowed in beneath a low white sky, snug against winter’s ice on the drift  down the Saint Lawrence River. The snow came hard overnight and morning brought a brief sun and the news from the  far west that a 22 year old waif of a skier, Alex Bilodeau, had thumped his way down the moguls to win Canada’s first Olympic gold medal upon home ground.

In victory he didn’t holler, whoop, punch air, hold a finger to the sky or engage in any of  the other victor’s passages of self that we have come to accept as easy ritual. He looked down and instead thanked his wheel chair bound older brother whose long and stoic acceptance  of his cerebral palsy has provided the champion’s inspiration.

His grace was in stark contrast to the Canadian-born Australian, Dale Begg-Smith, whose chilly antics after coming second in the same event have seen scorned as a sore-losing sourpuss. 

The triumph of the Bilodeau family enlarged this nation - which appeared to greet the one Gold medal it had been told it must, at the very least, win in Vancouver, not with a release of noisy nationalism but rather a coy relief  and a clap.  Within the soupy, steamed up cafes and the old timber bars in Quebec it seemed the victory offered more an opportunity for Canadians to quietly show two fingers to those among them who’ve wanted the urgers and boosters to this time step up, shoulder aside a nation’s temperament and plunder medals with a patriotic blood-lust.

The urgers came, as always, in corporate dress.

After Vancouver, in 2004, won the bid to stage this year’s Winter Olympics, they set out to convince Canadians that they should despair that they were the only nation to have hosted the Olympics – Montreal in 1976 and Calgary in 1988 - not to have won gold. Corporate and Government money began to pour into new athletes’ training facilities, coaches and technology.  They found a name for the effort that swaggered; Own The Podium.

Glittering coaches from Europe were brought in on puffed up salaries. Athletes were showered with ramped up cost-of-living-allowances .Soon the Canadian Olympic Committee began to speak of the expected outcomes which it said would be no fewer than 35 medals - and 12 of them gold. Canada would be expected to come first overall in Vancouver. Even Dick Pound, Canada’s eminence on the International Olympic Committee, spoke of those Canadian athletes who would fail to ascend the podium as tourists.

Indeed, their Prime Minister, Stephen Harper, urged Canadians to rise up and shout down the world at Vancouver even if he refined the act as “an outburst of uncharacteristic patriotism.”

Canada’s Olympic hierarchy began to show a new flintiness.

The Own the Podium chiefs banned the United States speed skater Catherine Rainey from practising on their new Olympic oval in British Columbia. They managed to cast aside the fact that Canada’s skaters had happily trained alongside Rainey for years. We now know they also tightly restricted practice for foreign teams on the new luge run at Whistler. That might have contributed to the death there before the opening ceremony of Georgia’s 21 year old Nodar Kumaritashvili who appeared to misjudge the potency of the track, lose control and slam into a metal column.

In that country in which the heroic loser has no high place – the United States – such a determination to succeed would not be questioned.  And, hardly, the less so in Australia, which the supporters of the Own The Podium movement are keen to point out, has long outspent Canada on the preparation of its Olympians with grand results.

So it is the more remarkable to see and feel in Canada, even as the Winter Olympics begin with the possibility that the boosters and urgers will triumph, a foreboding over what turn and what path the country has chosen by elevating the trample to win over the joy to compete, the big-mouthed bravado of the boosters over the quieter dignity of supporters.

Has something been lost?

The Montreal Gazette’s elegant columnist, John Freed, was among those who at the weekend pricked the outsized chests of the Own The Podium movement with Canadian self-deprecation.

Freed wrote: “As a nation, we’ve always been conditioned to accept defeat graciously and even revel in it. Like many, I root for Canada during most events, but the calm, confident inner knowledge that we won’t win gold – or if we do, we will fail the drug test.”

Various Canadian Olympians have also emerged to question the Own the Podium swagger.

Champion skier Sara Renner said at the weekend that while the extra money had brought her added training time, she and her colleagues never thought about owning the podium – just about skiing better.

Bruce Kidd, a runner, who won gold for Canada and later ran in the 5000 metres as an Olympian – he is now Dean of physical education at the University of Toronto – went further, saying: “I am embarrassed by ‘Own the Podium’ to this extent: we’re saying, ‘World, come to Canada so we can beat the shit out of you.”

It is true that here in Quebec, I am some 3500 kilometres from Vancouver and in a part of this enormous and diverse country that sees itself as removed from Canada’s mainstream.

But over here they still know that those who’ve set out to Own the Podium have also set themselves up for an enormous bite on the arse. And meanwhile the snow will still paint this world, the ice flows still mesmerize and a cripple in a wheelchair still inspire. Medals or not.

31 comments

  • Person launching self into air on skis for the adoration of millions of similarly brain-dead "sports fans"?

    Care factor: Zero

    Commenter
    Colin
    Location
    Jeffrey
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 10:55AM
  • Person commenting on a subject of which they have no interest in just to release their valve of insecurity and justifiying this by belittling millions of adoring "sports fans" by putting them in inverted commas?

    Friends: Zero

    Get a life Colin

    Commenter
    Wagga Magpie
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 11:59AM
  • Yes anyone that gets any sorts of enjoyment from sport must be a brain dead.

    Stupid comment factor: 100

    If everyone could do it, I'd agree, but it's a talent neither I nor you posses (I assume) and for that reason I get great enjoyment at seeing how far a human can push the boundaries of what is possible on skis

    Commenter
    Rob Weber
    Location
    England
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:14PM
  • own the podium has turned into a bit of a farce, no canadian likes to admit that training time has been cut to internationals and now due to weather concerns further cuts have occurred. the death on the luge track can be linked to a lack of training time but it can also be linked to the fact that this is the fastest luge track in history. the evidence in that is they have restricted athletes to launching from the females spot instead of the males. in know way im a trying to justify this tragic event.

    when it comes to the money that canada has put into its athletes it has long been lacking compared to what the US and Australians put in for their athletes.

    this is a great article and i hope would hope that more canadians see what the rest of the world thinks about "own the podium"

    Commenter
    mat
    Location
    canada
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:20PM
  • re: Dale Begg-Smith - he wins demurely and loses (or comes second in this case) in the same manner. To call him a sour puss is going a stretch to far in my opinion... but it's a great angle to incite the visceral reaction within us all.

    Commenter
    Hugh
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:23PM
  • Begg-Smith reminds me of many of the Canadians I've met, they're not generally all that extroverted, and eschew glitz and BS. He also skiied one of the best mogul runs I've ever seen, technically he was all over the guy who won, who was coming apart all over the place. Having a scoring system that rewards someone for skiing down faster, and managing to avoid crashing, isn't a good way to go IMO.

    Begg-Smith's form in that run will be used as an example of superb mogul skiing for years.

    Commenter
    ant
    Location
    Rural NSW
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:37PM
  • Anyone who follows Dale Begg-Smith would realise that he is a serious guy all of the time. He is THE clinical technician of this sport and many experts rate his moguls turns as the best ever. Clearly his complete seriousness towards his sport matches his personality. Not that there is anything wrong with that.

    If you'd seen his interview prior to the final, his attitude was exactly the same. He was focused and serious. Subsequently, you can't really argue that he was unsporting when he finished second. He was still his usual serious self.

    Alex Bilodeau did "holler, whoop, punch air" among other celebrations both when he finished his excellent run to be given the winning score, and mroeso when the following and final skier Gilbaut Colas failed to beat his score. Not that there was anything wrong with this. He celebrated an amazing victory in front of a massive and appreciative home crowd. Any less of a celebration would have been a letdown.

    As I have seen in too many of these National Times opinion pieces, the author starts off with an inaccurate and poorly researched story to lead into the real point of their story. If you are going to entice the reader to read your opinion piece, at least start off with a more factually accurate story to segue from.

    Commenter
    Will
    Location
    Centennial Park
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:48PM
  • I would like to agree with Hugh on Dale Begg-Smith. I have watched him compete since he became an Australian competitor and have never seen great remonstration or demonstrable emotion.

    When being interviewed recently about his recovery from an injury that has caused him to compete in pain for some time he seemed quiet, pleased and determined. When asked about his confidence he simply replied "Confidence isn't a problem".

    For Australian sports fans used to seeing Mundine or Sailor copy the outlandish noise of confidence that athletes of the USA display, this should be a welcome relief or at least an insight into a person that is a little more complicated than we are used to.

    Begg-Smith claimed silver in much the same manner that he took gold four years ago. The fact that he came back from awful surgery to do so is usually the recipe for an "against all odds" story in this country, not name calling. It seems he has a lot in common with Wayne Bennet, who is an example of the way that the Australian press always seeks to vilify those who would prefer to keep to themselves and ascribes emotions or thoughts to their reactions simply because they don't give good copy.

    Commenter
    ewen
    Location
    sydney
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:51PM
  • ant - I think Bilodeau did deserve to win. Mogul skiing is scored in the following way:

    Turns - 50%
    Jumps - 25%
    Time - 25%

    Begg-Smith was very close. He needed to be about 0.4 seconds faster down the hill and he would have won.

    Commenter
    Will
    Location
    Centennial Park
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 12:56PM
  • I'm sick of people whinging about D B-S. Is there only 1 type of personality sports people are allowed to have? He's done more than pretty much everyone of his critics (save for P FitzSymons).

    Believe it or not there are people in the world who are not bubbly extroverts who perform for the camera like a trained seal.Just be grateful he's won us medals - like all the other Australian-imports. Were you whinging when Tatiana Grigorieva and Dimitry Markov were winning medals at Sydney 2000?

    Commenter
    gabe@fitzroy
    Date and time
    February 16, 2010, 1:02PM

More comments

Comments are now closed