JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

New feature Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings View Demo

Hi there! Beta version

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

National Times

We must raise the legal age of drinking to 19

Ian Hickie
November 19, 2009

Opinion

There are calls to raise the legal age of drinking to 19 because of growing evidence about the impact of alcohol on a maturing brain.

There are calls to raise the legal age of drinking to 19 because of growing evidence about the impact of alcohol on a maturing brain.

Really smart countries now have a national agenda to maximise not just the ''mental health'' of their citizens but also their collective ''mental wealth''.

To achieve that aim, we need to look at the best ways to help young people reach their full cognitive and behavioural capacities. In that respect, national health, education and social policies should be informed by modern science.

New research in neuro-science tells us that the brain continues to develop right through until the late teenage and early adult period. In fact, particularly in young men, it may not reach adult maturity till the mid-20s.

It is the frontal part of the brain that regulates complex decision making, forward planning and inhibition of impulsive behaviours that is undergoing final development at this age.

One of the most toxic things that a young brain can encounter is a high level of blood alcohol.

The evidence from animal models of teenage intoxication, and recent brain imaging studies among teenagers who binge drink, is clear.

Longer-lasting brain changes and related neuro-psychological impairments can result from excessive use of alcohol during this critical period.

As we enter the annual national madness of ''schoolies'' week, it's time we really took some harder choices about the regulation of access to alcohol among young Australians.

The current legal age of 18 runs across a whole series of other major life changes: finishing school, starting university, learning to drive, getting a first job, entering a first sexual relationship - these are all major rites of passage.

Sadly, in our country we have now made them largely rites of intoxication.

The health and social risks of linking binge drinking to each of these major developmental stages is obvious. National media focus over the next few weeks will again put the issue on the national agenda.

The Prime Minister and the Health Minister are out touring the country and asking for serious health reform proposals, particularly in the areas of preventative and youth health.

While the evidence related to the benefits that could be derived from lifting the drinking age are clear, to date, there has been little political stomach for the task.

It is clear to those of us in health and social policy that simply lifting the age to 19 would break the current impasse and deliver immediate benefits.

The benefits would be most direct for those in their last year of school or their first year of university or employment. However, the benefits would also extend to a younger group since there is a clear relationship between the legal drinking age and first use of alcohol.

Given that Prime Minister Kevin Rudd meets all the premiers on December 7 to discuss health reform, our national government has an ideal opportunity to put a simple clear proposal on the national agenda.

Rather than focusing on more advertising, education and marketing, let's do something that will have real impact.

Lift the age to 19 and make a real difference now.

Professor Ian Hickie is the executive director of Sydney University's Brain and Mind Research Institute.

33 comments

  • I started at 16, and completed high school, went to university, and secured a good job.
    However now that I am older, I am ok with not endorsing the serving of alcohol to under 19's.
    If it was proposed to go to under 21's I'd be ok with that too.
    Good luck policing it though.

    Commenter
    I'm ok with that
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 11:26AM
  • Oh go on, whoever's in charge of this country: take the bull by the horn and raise the legal drinking age to 21. If the most liberal and democratic nation in the world, the United States, was able to do this years ago, so can little Australia. There'll always be underage drinking, but at least the paradigm will have shifted northward by three years and, for one thing, no longer will there be still impressionable and peer-pressured 17 year olds waiting with bated breath to enter a pub or club to enable them to get sloshed (and/or, by the way, lose their money at the "electronic chook-raffle machines").

    Never mind about the plonk industry which, from my observation has, in the last generation or so, been the prime mover to "alcoholise" our youth. After all, which is more important: extra profits generated from the industry's pursuit of the "kiddie-liquordollar", or the urgent need for a substantial reduction of alcohol-induced violence in streets, venues and homes, together with the avoidance of physical and mental health problems the young may experience, which further burdens the nation's already costly health services?

    Commenter
    Quonishant
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 1:54PM
  • Part of the journey to adulthood is about responsibility. Attitudes are caught not taught and parents are in the best position here to make a change to those destructive behaviours with respect to under age and binge drinking.

    Together with leaders from Government, tertiary education, the workplace, and sports establishments, Prof Hickie's message can be reinforced, that is the benefits of a healthy respect for alcohol.

    Prof Hickie has more professional experience than "Joe Public" as to the effects of binge drinking on the brains of young people, I would defer to his knowledge and recommendations.

    I note the recent TV advertisements as to the Drinkwise campaign, I urge any responsible parent to get informed and have a look.

    So Mr Rudd has on the agenda for next months Premiers meeting the issue of binge drinking and young people... Now we are looking for some LEADERSHIP from one Kevin Rudd....., spotlights on you Kev. (take a deep breath Australia)

    Commenter
    tim
    Location
    Concord
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 2:12PM
  • I'm always a little amused at arguments about the drinking age - we never had a legal drinking age until the 20th century and, in fact, much of society functioned in a state of semi-inebriation in the 18th and early 19th centuries.

    The Duke of Wellington was considered a "temperate" drinker for his habit of only having three or four glasses of claret an evening, followed by a few glasses of port and brandy.

    Small beer was the normal drink - and yes, it was around the same level of alcohol as now - about 4% to 5%.

    There's a certain amount of keeping the lower classes in their place here and a hefty dose of wowserism. There are issues around alcohol - especially regarding motor vehicles - but we have laws for that. Violence is far more of a cultural artifact and a policing issue. We don't need increased penalties to stop violent crime - if serious penalties worked the first fleet would have bhad no passengers - we need to ensure that those who commit crime are caught. Being caught is a far bigger deterrent than even the most extreme penalty.

    Commenter
    Anthony
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 4:19PM
  • If its the age causese all these issues then why do countries in Europe, who have some of the lowest age limits in the world, have the lewast amount of binge drinking issues??

    It doesn matter what age you move it to, its a culture thing - all you'll end up with is a bunch of p!ssed 19/20 yr olds. You can't 'grow out of something' until you have gone through it, its like diapers.

    Commenter
    Nikki
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 4:33PM
  • What's the difference?
    I grew up with kids who have been drinking since their mid teens. I moved to the US where underage drinking is just as rife despite their the legal drinking age of 21. Then I came back, and found the underage drinking problem in Australia is getting even worse.

    Commenter
    Kate
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 4:51PM
  • They can change the legal age to whatever they want - it won't stop anyone from drinking. If anything, it will encourage dangerous unsupervised binge drinking for yet another year. Getting pissed is part of the Australian culture. Look at Europe with no real age restrictions and yet they have the lowest rates of alcoholosn. Instead look at all the teenage drunken idiots in USA where the legal age is 21. Its related to culture and also rebellion, not age.

    Commenter
    Di
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 8:20PM
  • Are Americans the smartest people in the world?? By your reasoning they must as the legal age of drinking is 21!! Europeans on the hand start drinking much younger and yet they are not plagued with imbiciles!!

    Raise the age of drinking and all you will do is increase drug intake. Simple really - young people are going to have a good time no matter what.

    The wowsers are at it again - its insidious and it is chipping away slowly at our freedom of choice and self responsibility. The only thing that will make stunt brain growth is a nanny state.

    Commenter
    matster
    Location
    alexandria
    Date and time
    November 19, 2009, 9:51PM
  • Ha! Good luck enforcing this fantasy! In an age when kids have their first alchohol expereicne at 13+ you think barring under 19s from pubs and clubs is going to make a difference!? pull the other one you clown, and don't waste my time with fantasy. i deal in reality. all this will do is keep kids drinking in houses and homes for longer. its not the age of a drinker which needs addressing, but the culture of drinking and Australia's immature boofhead relationship with booze that needs the makeover. Nip the problem in the bud, don't simply delay it until another day.

    Commenter
    Dannygolucky
    Date and time
    November 20, 2009, 12:16AM
  • If you did lift the drinking age from eighteen to nineteen i will simply just waste my meager savings on a store of alcohol to see me through the few months till i m nineteen. This is a really bad idea by the way, a underfunded education system does more harm to the brains of children, and trash commercial TV for that matter, than alcohol ever will.

    Commenter
    E.Blair
    Location
    Perth.WA.
    Date and time
    November 20, 2009, 5:10AM

More comments

Comments are now closed